Innovation: Filling in the Gaps
October 1, 2011 By: Umar Iqbal, Jacques Georgy, Michael J. Korenberg, Aboelmagd Noureldin GPS WorldImproving Navigation Continuity Using Parallel Cascade Identification
To reliably navigate with fewer than four satellites, GPS pseudoranges need to be augmented with measurements from other sensors, such as a reduced inertial sensor system or RISS. What is the best way to combine the RISS measurements with the GPS measurements? The classic approach is to integrate the measurements in a conventional tightly coupled Kalman filter. But in this month’s column, we look at how a mathematical procedure called parallel cascade identification can improve the Kalman filter’s job, when navigating with three, two, or even one GPS satellite.
INNOVATION INSIGHTS by Richard Langley
 Richard Langley |
THREE, TWO, ONE, ZERO! Can you still navigate with just a GPS receiver when the number of tracked GPS satellites drops from four to none? As we know, pseudoranges from a minimum of four satellites, preferably well spaced out in the sky, are required for three-dimensional positioning. That’s because there are four unknowns to estimate: the three position coordinates (latitude, longitude, and height) and the offset of the receiver clock from GPS System Time. If we had a stable clock in the receiver, then we could hold the clock offset constant and have 3D navigation with just three satellites. But for every 3 nanoseconds of clock drift, we will have about 1 meter of pseudorange error, which will lead to several meters of position error depending on the receiver-satellite geometry. On the other hand, we could hold the height coordinate constant (viable for navigation over slowly changing topography or at sea) and estimate the horizontal coordinates and the receiver clock offset. So far, so good.
What if the number of tracked satellites then drops to two? We can now only estimate two unknowns. They could be the two horizontal coordinates, if we hold both the receiver clock offset and the height fixed. Any errors in those fixed values will propagate into the estimated horizontal coordinates but the resulting position errors might still be acceptable. Instead of holding the clock offset fixed, we could assume a constant heading and compute the position along the assumed trajectory. However, navigation will rapidly deteriorate as soon as we make the first turn. And one satellite? We would have to make assumptions about the vehicle trajectory, the height, and the clock offset, with likely very poor results. And with no satellites? We might be able to navigate over a short period of time by “dead reckoning,” assuming a constant trajectory and speed, but the resulting positions will be educated guesses at best.
Clearly, if we want to reliably navigate with fewer than four satellites we need to augment the GPS pseudoranges with measurements from some other sensors. A common approach is to use inertial measurement units or IMUs. A complete IMU consists of three accelerometers and three gyroscopes, and small, cost-effective microelectromechanical IMUs are readily available. For land navigation, however, it can be advantageous to use a reduced inertial sensor system or RISS, consisting of one single-axis gyroscope, two accelerometers, and the vehicle speedometer. We can also make use of GPS pseudorange rates along with the pseudoranges.
But what is the best way to combine the RISS measurements with the GPS measurements? The classic approach is to integrate the measurements in a conventional tightly coupled Kalman filter. But in this month’s column, we look at how a mathematical procedure called parallel cascade identification can improve the Kalman filter’s job, when navigating with three, two, or even one GPS satellite.
The Global Positioning System meets the requirements for numerous navigational applications when there is direct line-of-sight (LOS) to four or more GPS satellites. Vehicular navigation systems and personal positioning systems may suffer from satellite signal blockage as LOS to at least four satellites may not be readily available when operating in urban landscapes with high buildings, underpasses, and tunnels, or in the countryside with thick forested areas. In such environments, a typical GPS receiver will have difficulties attaining and maintaining signal tracking, which causes GPS outages resulting in degraded or non-existent positioning information. Due to these well-known limitations of GPS, multi-sensor system integration is often employed. By integrating GPS with complementary motion sensors, a solution can be obtained that is often more accurate than that of GPS alone.
Microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) inertial sensors have enabled production of lower-cost and smaller-size inertial measurement units (IMUs) with little power consumption. A complete IMU is composed of three accelerometers and three gyroscopes. These MEMS sensors have composite error characteristics that are stochastic in nature and difficult to model. In traditional low-cost MEMS-based IMU/GPS integration, a few minutes of degraded GPS signals can cause position errors, which can reach several hundred meters. For full 3D land vehicle navigation, we had earlier proposed a low-cost MEMS-based reduced inertial sensor system (RISS) based on only one single-axis gyroscope, two accelerometers, and the vehicle odometer, and we have integrated this system with GPS. RISS mitigates several error sources in the full-IMU solution; moreover, RISS reduces system cost further due to the use of fewer sensors. Another enhancement can be achieved by using tightly coupled integration, which can provide GPS aiding for a navigation solution when the number of visible satellites is three or lower, removing the foremost requirement of loosely coupled integration, which is visibility of at least four satellites. GPS aiding during limited GPS satellite availability can improve the operation of the navigation system for tightly coupled systems. Thus, in our reseach, a Kalman filter (KF) is used to integrate low-cost MEMS-based RISS with GPS in a tightly coupled scheme.
The KF employed in tightly coupled RISS/GPS integration utilizes pseudoranges and pseudorange rates measured by the GPS receiver. The accuracy of the position estimates is highly dependent on the accuracy of the range measurements. The tightly coupled solutions presented in the literature assume that the pseudorange measurement, after correcting for ionospheric and tropospheric delays, satellite clock errors, and ephemeris errors, only have errors due to the receiver clock and white noise. These latter two are the only errors modeled inside the measurement model in the tightly coupled solutions presented in the literature. Experimental investigation of the GPS pseudoranges for vehicle trajectories in different areas and for different scenarios showed that, in addition, there are residual correlated errors. Since it has been experimentally proven that there are residual correlated errors in addition to white noise and receiver clock errors, we have proposed using a nonlinear system identification technique called parallel cascade identification (PCI) to model such correlated errors in pseudorange measurements.
1 2 3 4 5 6
RSS
Become a Fan
Join our Network
Follow Us
Please send any technical comments or questions to our webmaster.